
Facebook's early culture before the days of the News Feed or multiple redesigns was vastly different. Facebook was like collecting baseball cards. Random people would meet me at a party or conference and later find me on Facebook. Since there was no real consequence, the friend number would tick up on my profile and I slowly amassed over 500 friends.
Then came Friendfeed and Twitter, intriguing web apps where you could track the every movement of your friends and colleagues - people you selected because you desire their thoughts. As these networks gained steam, Mark Zuckerburg decided that he wanted Facebook, and no other site, to be the center of people's online lives. So he turned Facebook into Friendfeed and Twitter, but there was a big problem...
All of the random people I met once? I do not care what they are eating right now. I don't care to see pictures of them and their "bros" beer pong tournaments, I don't care what their Top Five beers are, I don't care that they just bought tickets to Jonas Brothers 3D, and finally I don't care that they share characteristics with President Willard Filmore.
The newly enhanced filters address this issue, but it does not fix it or stop all of those random people from learning random information about me.
For advertisers and companies that are excited about the new way their updates can work their way into people's feeds, this is also not great news. Will their messages get to ANY of their public effectively or get lost in the white noise of a thousand random people's updates?
The way to fix this issue is going through all my Facebook friends and deleting all the random people, but that is a lengthy process that causes more problems than it fixes. Even with an excuse of getting free Burger King, the old culture of "collecting Facebook baseball cards" is still there and deleting someone is the ultimate online slap in the face.
So what is the answer?
Facebook needs to decide what it is - a communications tool and directory of close friends or a bloated jack-of-all-trades, that is a master of none.
